Better Than the Pilgrims: Five Affordable Wines for a Five-Course Thanksgiving

SIG HERMANSEN
Columnist
news@lbknews.com

Five courses, five pairings and not a mug of Pilgrim beer in sight: quality Thanksgiving wines that cost less than the supermarket names, some for under $10.

—The Pilgrims had learned to substitute beer and hard apple cider for the polluted supply of public drinking water in England. We know little about the beers and ales, wines and spirits the Pilgrims drank during the 1620s in New England, but we think that we can do better than the Pilgrims.

Sig Hermansen

—Following a rough outline of a Thanksgiving feast, we suggest quality and affordable wines for each of five courses. Some of the courses have suggested wine alternatives to accommodate different tastes. Some of the suggested wines sell for under $10. Most sell for less than popular supermarket brands of the same variety.

—First Course: Bubbles and Havarti

—Mini toasts topped with thin slices of Havarti cheese sprinkled with oregano flakes and sprigs of parsley. Lightly toasted.

—The wine: Tissot-Maire Blanc de Blancs Crémant du Jura Brut.

—This crisp sparkling wine comes from the same Chardonnay grape as Blanc de Blancs (white wine made with white grapes) Champagne and is made the same way. The hint of butter in the toasts and herbs mingles with the bubbles rising from the Crémant in the glass.

—Second Course: Bread, Oil and a Conversation Starter

—Bread cubes impaled with toothpicks for dipping in saucers filled with flavored olive oil (light, garlic, rosemary, anchovy). An intentionally light prelude to the heavier main courses.

—The wine: Argiolas Costamolino Vermentino.

—This lovely golden white wine from Sardinia, Italy, has become an alternative to Chardonnay by the glass in local bars and restaurants. An excellent sipping wine, it helps start conversations: “Have you heard of this wine?”

—Third Course: The Bird, White Meat and Dark

—Turkey and dressing; sweet potatoes; green bean casserole with slivered almonds; cranberry sauce; brown gravy to pour over the turkey.

—White for the breast slices: Chateau Ste. Michelle Gewurztraminer 2025.

—This Northern Italian variety of grape finds a friendly space in Eastern Washington State. A floral and off-dry wine, it adds the moisture and nectar that bring out the flavors in turkey breast.

—Red for the dark meat slices: Wente Family Vineyards’ Baily Hill Pinot Noir 2023.

—The softer tannins in this bargain wine enrich the meaty tastes of the legs and thighs of the larger bird. The wine has evolved over centuries as an ideal sauce for gamy birds.

—Fourth Course (Optional): For the Meat-and-Potatoes Crowd

—Pork loin, beefsteak or lamb with mashed potatoes for the red meat and potatoes fanciers.

—The wine: Guidobono Langhe Nebbiolo CV.

—This wine from the Piedmont has a lighter hue than many of the big Cabernet Sauvignons from California. It delivers a robust taste nonetheless and stands up to red meat.

—Fifth Course: Pumpkin Pie and Porto

—Pumpkin pie with whipped cream.

—The wine: Porto Tawny Port.

—Matching a sweet fortified wine from Portugal to a sweet dessert seems too obvious. Yet it works well, particularly when affordable quality tawny Porto sells for as little as $5 a fifth.

—Better Than the Pilgrims

—One could pay far more for wines for a Thanksgiving dinner. The selections we suggest offer quality at affordable prices.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Popular

Read our Latest...

On Patrol Longboat Key Police reports week of November 20, 2026

—Nov. 14 —Open and Shut Case —2:51 p.m. —Officer Castro and Officer...

Sarasota Letters to the Editor week of November 20, 2026

—Kicked Upstairs, CC Included. —To: Shannon James. —Thank you for the...

Longboat Letters to the Editor week of November 20, 2026

—Passing the Leash. —To: Longboat Key Commissioner Sarah Karon —Yep, that's...