Rose Pointe Rezone Survives by One Vote as New Commissioner Casts a Silent No

STEVE REID
Editor & Publisher
sreid@lbknews.com

The 2.8-acre Beneva Road rezone is now law. The median, the driveway, the stormwater and even who owns the road are questions for another day.

—Kathy Kelley Ohlrich did her homework. Ahead of the vote, the newly appointed mayor went out to 1551 N. Beneva Road during the evening rush and, by her own account, “sort of hung around for a while” to see what the neighbors in Tallywood had been warning about since summer.

“Traffic really does back up going northbound on Beneva to make that left turn onto 17th Street,” she told her colleagues at the Nov. 16 City Commission meeting. The U-turns residents predicted, she said, are real, and the way they will mix with turning traffic at 17th Street is “really going to be quite problematic, I think.”

—Then she voted yes.

—So did Commissioners Liz Alpert and Kyle Battie. With that, the Rose Pointe rezone cleared its final hurdle on a 3-2 vote, moving 2.8 wooded acres just south of 17th Street from the city’s RMF-1 zone district to RMF-3 and opening the door to as many as 36 market-rate apartments where 16 units are allowed today. Under the ordinance, the rezone took effect immediately.

—The margin is the story. When the commission passed the ordinance on first reading Oct. 19, the vote was 4-1, with then-Mayor Debbie Trice in the majority and Commissioner Jen Ahearn-Koch the lone dissenter. Trice did not seek reelection. Her at-large seat now belongs to Flo Entler, a longtime neighborhood advocate elected Nov. 3.

—Entler voted no. She offered no explanation. Ahearn-Koch, now vice mayor, voted no again, also without comment. One more defection and Rose Pointe would have died on the final vote.

—Anyone who followed the case at the Planning Board will recognize the silent no. In September, board member Dan Clermont cast the only vote against the rezone there and didn’t say why either.

Chart of the three Rose Pointe rezone votes: 4-1 at the Planning Board, 4-1 on first reading and 3-2 on final adoption by the Sarasota City Commission
The Rose Pointe rezone passed the Planning Board and the City Commission’s first reading 4-1. After Mayor Debbie Trice retired and new Commissioner Flo Entler took her at-large seat, the final vote Nov. 16 was 3-2. Graphic: LBK News

—The whole item took about 14 minutes. In September, Tallywood residents waited more than five hours for their turn at the microphone.

—Homework at Rush Hour

—Ohlrich’s worry centers on the median that splits Beneva in front of the property. With the site’s access on the southbound side, she said, drivers coming up Beneva who want to get in will head to 17th Street and swing back around. “They’ll do what I call a flip turn, but most people call it a U-turn,” she said, adding that those drivers will be turning at the same moment the right-turn arrow is on for traffic heading east on 17th Street and turning south onto Beneva.

—Senior Planner Cristian Toellner said he knew the maneuver firsthand from when he lived off Fruitville Road and Lakewood Ranch Boulevard, where signs tell left-turning drivers to yield to oncoming right turns. “I don’t know if that is a solution,” he said.

—Toellner reminded the commission that the Planning Board struck the applicant’s right-in, right-out driveway proffer in September precisely to keep the city’s options open.

“There is a divider right there on that segment of Beneva Road,” he said. “That’s why we got rid of the proffers so we could have that option to determine whether we can take a left out from the proposed development onto North Beneva.”

—Ohlrich left it there. “Well, we’re not going to solve that problem today, but I wanted to bring it up for discussion and consideration at a future point.”

Diagram of Beneva Road between 12th and 17th streets showing the U-turns drivers would make to reach and leave the Rose Pointe site
Because of the Beneva Road median, every trip in and out of Rose Pointe uses the southbound lanes. Drivers arriving from the south would U-turn at 17th Street, and drivers leaving for points north would U-turn at 12th Street. Whether a left turn out across the median is possible will be studied at site plan review. Schematic, not to scale. Graphic: LBK News

—One Neighbor, One Email

—Tallywood’s turnout shrank to a single speaker. Suzanne Bishop, whose written statement to the Planning Board in September mapped the U-turn trap at 12th Street, came to the table in person and read an email she had sent commissioners a week earlier.

“As you enter the final stages of the process to approve increased density for this project, I urge you to visit the property if you have not done so already,” she read. She asked commissioners to picture “how vehicles wishing to head in the opposite direction will undoubtedly make U-turns at 12th and 17th Street,” and to weigh the long-term traffic and pedestrian safety hazards that would follow.

“I am not opposed to growth,” she said. “But I believe it must be smart, thoughtful, and appropriate for the community.”

—Her closing line was aimed squarely at the dais. “There is an important distinction between having the authority to approve this application for increased density and exercising judgment to determine whether approving it is truly in the best interest of the community.”

—At least one commissioner, it turned out, had already taken her up on the site visit.

—Whose Road Is It, Anyway?

—Bishop then tried to ask a question: Is Beneva Road a city road?

—City Auditor and Clerk Shayla Griggs cut her off. “Unfortunately, this is not question and answer.”

—Bishop explained why she was asking. “I didn’t know if they could make changes to the median.”

—It was not an idle question. Whoever controls that stretch of Beneva controls the median, and the median sits at the root of nearly every traffic complaint Tallywood has raised.

—The dais couldn’t settle it either. Battie interjected to correct the record, saying the road is the city’s. Ahearn-Koch then put Bishop’s question to staff herself. “I think it’s county,” she said. “Pretty sure it is.”

“I’m getting two different answers,” someone in the chamber said.

“We have everybody weighing in,” Ahearn-Koch replied.

—Development Services Director Lucia Panica offered the closest thing to an answer. “I believe Public Works would be the one to identify the street,” she said. “I believe it is a city street, just from past projects we’ve worked on.”

—Staff promised to run down the information. The vote came minutes later, with the question still open on the record.

—The Applicant’s Fix

—Brian Lichterman of Vision Planning & Design, the planning agent for the Jorge and Yda Arevalo Revocable Trust, which owns the land, kept his remarks short.

“As a professional land planner for over 40 years, I’m trying to make sure that this will be a good project and be a compatible neighbor,” he said, pointing to the list of stipulations he has attached to the request. “I believe that we’ve done that.”

—On Ohlrich’s U-turn concern, Lichterman, who noted he is not a traffic engineer, suggested a restriction on the right turn from eastbound 17th Street, which he said would keep U-turning drivers from tangling with traffic headed south. The chamber audio broke up before he finished.

—Alpert Wants the Building Moved

—Alpert, who made the motion to approve, first made sure of what she was voting on. “This is just approving the rezone. It’s not approving the site plan, correct?”

—Toellner confirmed it.

“I have a problem with the site plan, with the buildings being to the rear of the property instead of the front of the property,” Alpert said. “I’m hoping when the site plan comes back that there’s that change.”

—That would be a real departure from the nonbinding concept Lichterman showed the Planning Board in September, which turned the parking lots and car doors toward Beneva and away from Tallywood. Where the cars would go if the building moved forward is a question for the site plan, and one Tallywood will want answered.

—What October Added

—Rose Pointe picked up two more changes aimed at its neighbors at first reading Oct. 19, according to the city’s agenda materials.

—The commission struck the word “consider” from the pedestrian proffer, so the developer must now provide a sidewalk connection and a break in the perimeter wall linking the site to the businesses along 17th Street, not merely consider one. It also added a new requirement that the applicant hold a community workshop, coordinated with the Tallywood community, before submitting a site plan application.

—Those join the changes the Planning Board made in September. The right-in, right-out driveway proffer is gone, and the setbacks and landscape buffers along the western boundary must now exceed code rather than “meet or exceed” it.

—The final ordinance still caps the property at 36 units, the same number Planning Board member Douglas Christy pointed out in September is the most RMF-3 allows on the site anyway. It also requires any pool to be screened and kept off the western boundary to cut noise for Tallywood, an opaque fence or wall along the north, west and south property lines, decorative paver and trellis features along the pedestrian walkway from Beneva, and coordination with Breeze Transit on a new or relocated bus stop near the property’s southern edge.

—One line in the ordinance speaks directly to a fear Tallywood’s Ann Black raised in September, that the owner could flip a more valuable entitlement to a buyer with different plans. The proffers, the ordinance states, “shall run with the land as restrictive covenants and shall bind all future owners or successors.”

Scale drawing of the 2.8-acre Rose Pointe parcel on Beneva Road with the eight conditions in Ordinance 26-5612
The 2.8-acre Rose Pointe parcel, plotted to scale from the legal description in Ordinance 26-5612, with the conditions the developer must meet. The building’s location, the driveway and the stormwater design will be settled at site plan review. Graphic: LBK News

—Elections Have Consequences

—That phrase came from frequent commission critic Martin Hyde during public comment the morning of Nov. 16, as he congratulated Ahearn-Koch on her reelection, Entler on her election and the new mayor, “with hope that she will rediscover her former zeal for protecting our environment and neighborhoods.”

—The Rose Pointe roll call made his point in miniature. Trice’s yes on first reading became Entler’s no on second. Ohlrich, who voted yes as vice mayor in October, voted yes again as mayor.

—Entler, an Arlington Park neighborhood advocate (Arlington Park neighbors led the fight against the Midtown Plaza hotel at the Planning Board in September), campaigned against overdevelopment and on the argument that the commission wasn’t listening to residents. Her only question on Rose Pointe was procedural.

“Are we going to get a presentation from the developer or just staff?” she asked. “I’m just asking.”

—Griggs told her a presentation wasn’t needed for a second reading.

—Earlier that day, during the commission’s discussion of the rewrite of the city’s transportation plan, Entler had pressed staff on whether traffic projections account for the city’s growth. “We know how much Sarasota is growing,” she said. “Do we include or consider any future growth?”

—She didn’t connect that question to Rose Pointe, and she didn’t explain her vote.

Rose Pointe by the numbers: 2.8 acres, 16 to 36 apartments, a 3-2 final vote, 19 evening peak-hour trips, a 14-minute hearing and one Tallywood speaker
Rose Pointe by the numbers, from the 2.8-acre parcel to the 14-minute final hearing. Graphic: LBK News

—What Happens Next

—Winning the rezone doesn’t put a shovel in the ground. The ordinance says in plain terms that it “does not permit the development of the rezoned property.” Nothing can be built until a site plan is approved.

—Before the developer can even file one, the Tallywood workshop has to happen. After that, the plan goes through the city’s Development Review Committee, where engineers will study whether a left turn out across the Beneva median is possible. The committee is also where the stormwater concerns raised in September by Tallywood resident Juan Huerta, who estimated an inch of rain on the site would produce on the order of 70,000 gallons of runoff, will have to be answered with actual engineering. A traffic study deemed the project “de minimis” for now, but the city’s agenda materials note the full concurrency analysis must accompany a future site plan.

—In September, Planning Board member Alexander Neihaus told the residents who had sat through the five-hour hearing that, because of the conditions attached, the eventual site plan can’t be approved administratively and must come back to his board in public. “I look forward to seeing all of you then,” he said.

—Tallywood lost the zoning fight by a single vote. The fight over the building, the driveway, the water and the median is just getting started, and somebody at City Hall still has to figure out who owns the road.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Popular

Read our Latest...

Better Than the Pilgrims: Five Affordable Wines for a Five-Course Thanksgiving

Five courses, five pairings and not a mug of...

On Patrol Longboat Key Police reports week of November 20, 2026

—Nov. 14 —Open and Shut Case —2:51 p.m. —Officer Castro and Officer...

Sarasota Letters to the Editor week of November 20, 2026

—Kicked Upstairs, CC Included. —To: Shannon James. —Thank you for the...

Longboat Letters to the Editor week of November 20, 2026

—Passing the Leash. —To: Longboat Key Commissioner Sarah Karon —Yep, that's...