The voters said enough. The construction money was collected for somebody else’s neighborhood. And this island was never short on books. In December, the County Commission should close the cover.
—Let me start with a confession that will cost me at dinner parties. I was an English major. I went to graduate school for literature, voluntarily and at my own expense. I have owned thousands of books, and I want every person in this county reading every novel, newspaper and periodical they can get their hands on.

—And I am telling you the Longboat Key library should be shelved. Not paused. Not signed, sealed and slipped into a drawer until the weather improves. Stopped.
—It is the wrong building, paid for with the wrong money, in the wrong place, at the worst possible time. Other than that, I have no objections.
—A Solution in Search of a Problem
—Start with the supposed emergency, which is that Longboaters cannot get to a library.
—The Town Center Green is about eight miles from Selby Library in downtown Sarasota, the biggest branch in the county system. For the north end, Manatee County’s Island Library in Holmes Beach is the closer one. Virtually no one on this island lives more than about 10 miles from a public library. The island has also had a small volunteer library of its own for nearly 70 years.
—That is before we count the libraries in everyone’s other states. A good many Longboaters have a summer place, or a mountain place, or a place near the ski lift, and I am reliably informed that those towns have libraries too. The typical resident here is a short drive from a public library in at least two time zones.
—Then there are the books themselves. Most of us moved here with a personal library. We offered it to the kids. The kids, who do not want our books any more than they want our china, turned it down. So it went to Goodwill, and we bought a Kindle or an iPad.
—Longboaters know how to get online. They know how to research, how to send email, how to ask an AI a question and then argue with the answer. To suggest this community has been sitting in the dark, waiting for the county to deliver the written word, is almost condescending.
—What Longboat Wanted Was a Room
—Here is the honest history. For years the dream was an arts and cultural center, a Longboat project to be paid for by Longboat. The partnership with Ringling College fell apart. The county library arrived as the make-good, pushed hard by former Mayor Ken Schneier.
—But listen to what residents asked for at the 2024 workshops. They asked for a real meeting hall. And look at what the island’s donors bought, in the words of the town’s own planning staff: “an enlarged community meeting space, covered outdoor terrace on the Green, and an enhanced entry.”
—A hall, a terrace and a nice front door. The books are the cover story. What we are building is a clubhouse with a card catalog.
—And we have clubhouses. We have the Key Club. We have condominium common rooms from one end of Gulf of Mexico Drive to the other, every one of them equipped with chairs, air conditioning and a neighbor with strong opinions about the landscaping budget. We have the Green itself and its pavilion, which by my eye have been underused since the day they opened. I have not seen anything close to a full calendar of concerts out there.
—If we cannot fill the gathering place we already built, I doubt the cure is a bigger one that the county has to staff.
—There Is No Free Library

—The fiscal conservative in me is offended by the sales pitch, which is that this is a gift. Impact fees build it, donors dress it up, and Longboat gets a library for nothing.
—There is no free money. There never has been.
—The county’s own finance chief put the operating bill at about $740,000 for a partial first year, $1.1 million for the first full year and roughly $1.4 million a year by 2031. Not one dollar of that can come from impact fees or donations. All of it comes out of the county’s general fund, which runs on property taxes, which the voters of Florida just cut.
—The county expects to lose $46.85 million in fiscal 2028 and $87.09 million the year after. Its library department had 18 vacant positions in October, with hiring paused. The Longboat branch now sits on a nine-project review list alongside a jail addition and two fire stations.
—It is not free on this end, either. The town has agreed to lease its land to the county at no charge for up to 80 years and to maintain the property.
—Whose Money Is It, Anyway?
—Now my inner liberal would like a word, because he is angrier than the conservative.
—About $11 million of this building comes from library impact fees. An impact fee is what a new house pays so that public services can keep up with the growth that house creates. It is the one charge in government with its purpose stamped right on it.
—Longboat Key is not growing. It is built out. Its population has flatlined. So that $11 million did not, by and large, come from here. It came from new rooftops in places like North Port and Wellen Park and the subdivisions marching east of the interstate, where homes are approved by the thousand and where some families face a longer drive to a branch than anyone on this island.
—We have a county government that has staked its entire financial future on growth and then declines to fund what the growth requires. Sarasota County has not opened a new library anywhere since 2018. After all that building, its next one would go on a barrier island with a flat population and a private beach club, so that we can have a terrace.
—Those homeowners out east already paid. They cannot be billed twice. If their fees are spent here, the next library in their part of the county waits on money from houses that have not been built yet, in a market nobody can predict. That is a shell game, and it does not lift literacy by a single page.
—Four of the five county commissioners represent districts that do not contain a grain of Longboat sand. I would like to hear one of them explain this at a town hall. Your impact fees built a lovely library on Longboat Key. You are welcome to drive out and visit. Yours will be along when the next few thousand homes get permitted.
—This is not a gift to Longboat. It is a public taking.
—Two Hats, One Project
—The project gets sold two ways. On the island, the message is that it is practically free. At the county, the message is that Longboat pays a great deal in taxes and deserves its fair share of services.
—Is that really where Longboat wants to hang its hat? Demanding our cut, for something we do not need and do not much seem to want?
—One of the library’s most effective champions lives in both of those worlds. Commissioner Sarah Karon is one of the loveliest, most charming and most enthusiastic people you will ever meet. She and her husband have been generous to this island, and the pavilion carries their name. She has also spent years at the top of the Library Foundation for Sarasota County, the nonprofit that raises private money for the county’s libraries.
—I think it is wrong for one person to hold both megaphones on a project like this. Affection is not agreement.
—The fundraising tells its own story. It was supposed to run through the Longboat Key Foundation. In practice, much of the lifting fell to Karon and to then-Town Manager Howard Tipton, who was handed the job of spearheading it. A town manager is hired to run a town. Raising private money for a county building is what the executive director of a charity does, and the commission should never have dumped it on him.
—When the county signed off in June 2025, this newspaper reported the pledges had come from 12 people, with the town on the hook for any shortfall. The campaign did eventually beat its goal. But on an island with this much money, a thing people truly wanted would have been funded before the salad course.
—The Buchanan Discount
—Then there is the name over the door.
—County policy said the name on a building costs 25 percent of the project, or about $3.5 million here. U.S. Rep. Vern Buchanan and his wife, Sandy, pledged $1 million. The town asked the county to relax its rule, the county obliged, and the building became the Vern and Sandy Buchanan Sarasota County Library.
—A million dollars is real money and real generosity, and I do not sneer at it. But that is naming rights at roughly 70 percent off. The congressman built a car-dealership empire. He knows a markdown when he sees one.
—It is hard to see eye to eye with officials who insist on kneeling in a compromising position before the very person whose approval they seek.
—Now meet the son. State Sen. James Buchanan backed Amendment 3 and said on election night that a permanent tax cut is the best way to put government on a diet. Then came the matter of the library that would carry his parents’ names and cost the county more than a million dollars a year to run. He has said he would want to talk with town and county leaders about how it can still move forward.
—Everybody on a diet, in other words, except for dessert at our table.
—That is not a political position. That is a contortion act, and it belongs at a charity gala, somewhere between the silent auction and the flourless chocolate cake, where a half-drunk ballroom can watch a man say one thing, do another and bend toward a third, all in opposite directions.
—The Voters Already Voted
—Amendment 3 passed with about 62 percent statewide. Sarasota County gave it 62.6 percent. And at Longboat Key’s own Town Hall precinct, after town commissioners spent the fall warning residents what it would cost them, it got 61.5 percent.
—Longboat did not dissent. We voted like the rest of Florida.
—The town’s own lobbyist, Dave Ramba, said it plainly to the commission on Nov. 9: “62% is 62%, and people need to listen to what the voters said.”
—What they said is not complicated. They want an end to the exuberant years. They want government to stop building things that are merely nice to have because the money looked free. Libraries did not even make the amendment’s list of core functions. A specialty project on a wealthy island, sold as a gift, with a permanent bill attached, at a time of real fiscal uncertainty, is the exact thing they were voting against.
—Build Our Own, With Our Own
—I will grant the one reasonable need. Town Hall’s chambers seat about 80 people, and a town ought to have a room where it can gather.
—So let’s build one. Ours. Scaled way down to a size and cost that makes sense, fitted into the Green with beautiful landscaping and architecture worth looking at. More than $4 million in pledges goes back to the donors if the county walks. Ask them to leave it here if we must have a gathering space.
—Yes, we would have to pay to run it. That is what owning something means. If Longboat has the largesse everyone keeps telling the county it has, here is a chance to prove it — or not.
—Close the Cover
—The County Commission is set to take up its project list in December, with Dec. 15 as the working date. It takes three votes. It may not even take that. The town’s ordinance says that if the county does not accept the approval within 30 days of receiving it, the ordinance is “deemed to have been denied.”
—I have a feeling people are working behind the scenes to save this thing with some Hail Mary of funding. Please don’t. Do not torture the system, do not compound the problem and do not go against the plain will of the voters to rescue a building because the drawings are pretty.
—About a million dollars has gone into those drawings. Losing it will sting. There is a name for that, politically and emotionally: cutting your losses.
—Send the impact fees where the impact is. Send the donors their checks, or better, ask them to build the hall. And let’s stop funding a solution on Longboat Key to which there is no known problem.
